Capitol Hill Hearing Raises Alarm over Turkey and Azerbaijan’s Existential Threat to Christian Armenia

— CSI President Dr. John Eibner, Co-Chair Chris Smith Spotlight Artsakh Ethnic Cleansing, Turkey’s Region-Wide Persecution of ChristiansWASHINGTON, DC – After erasing Armenian Christians from Anatolia and, more recently, Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh), Turkey and Azerbaijan have now turned their sights on the Republic of Armenia itself, Christian Solidarity International (CSI) President Dr. John Eibner warned lawmakers at a Tom Lantos Human Rights Commission hearing on the worldwide persecution of Christians.
Eibner testified at the Commission’s November 18th hearing, “Worldwide Persecution of Christians: Responding to New Challenges,” co-chaired by Chris Smith (R-NJ) and James McGovern (D-MA). Smith called Turkish President Erdogan “an existential threat to Israel, to Greece and Armenia” and recounted his confrontations with Azerbaijani President Aliyev in Baku.
Video of the full hearing is available at:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rpc-XgWvZJw Dr. Eibner’s written testimony is available at:
https://anca.org/assets/pdf/111826_Eibner_TLHRC_testimony. “Dr. Eibner and Co-Chair Smith told the truth – the plain, hard truth – that Turkey and Azerbaijan, bound together in their ‘one nation, two states’ alliance, are working to finish what they started in 1915: the erasure of Armenian Christians from their indigenous lands,” said Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA) Executive Director Aram Hamparian. “From the Armenian Genocide, still unpunished, to the ethnic cleansing of Artsakh, to the hostages being held in Baku, to Aliyev’s aggressive claims on Armenia as ‘Western Azerbaijan’ – the regimes that target Armenians have never been made to pay a price. America has every tool it needs to stop them. What has been missing, under administrations of both parties, is the will to use them – and that starts with ending the arms, the aid, and the diplomatic cover that Washington provides to Ankara and Baku.”
Exposing Turkey’s Campaign Against Christians
Dr. Eibner zeroed in on what he called “the sustained threat to vulnerable Christian communities in the increasingly militarized and aggrandizing spheres of influence of the one nation, two states combination of Turkey and Azerbaijan,” describing it as “one of the great emerging threats, not only to Christians, but other religious minorities.”
He traced Turkey’s conduct to the founding of the Turkish Republic. “The militant, anti-democratic, ethno-religious nationalism that today drives persecution of Christian communities in Turkey has deep historical roots. It emerged at the foundation of the Republic of Turkey, as a synthesis of the ideologies of Islamism and ultra-Turkish nationalism,” Eibner stated in his written testimony. Turkey’s Christian population — Armenians, Greeks, Syriacs, Assyrians, and Aramaeans — has fallen from 20 percent at the time of the Armenian Genocide to less than one percent, he told the Commission.
Eibner noted that the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) has urged the Secretary of State to place Turkey on the State Department’s Special Watch List of severe religious freedom violators, a recommendation that has not been fulfilled.
Co-Chair Smith, who recounted holding two hearings urging the President to raise human rights with Erdogan ahead of his visit to Ankara, called for a far tougher U.S. posture toward Turkey. “In my humble opinion, Turkey should be on the CPC [State Department Country of Particular Concern] list and they ought to be sanctioned for what they do,” Smith said.
Smith recalled a Turkish ambassador’s threat during a series of hearings he chaired on the Armenian Genocide. “He looked at me and he said, you know, if you guys recognize the Armenian Genocide, we’re going to throw you out of Incirlik, the base that we have there. What a NATO friend and ally that is,” Smith said. Contrasting Erdogan with postwar German Chancellor Konrad Adenauer’s reckoning with Nazi crimes, he added: “And yet we have this culture of denial on the part of Erdogan and others.”
Smith challenged potential sales of F-35 fighter jets and other advanced weaponry to Ankara. “I even asked in a briefing with some administration people, what is the threat to Turkey that is so compelling that they need F-35s?” he said. “It’s just mind-boggling that a man like that could get away.”
Confronting Azerbaijan’s Genocidal Ethnic Cleansing of Artsakh
Eibner described Azerbaijan’s systematic erasure of Armenian Christian communities within its borders. “Where are the Armenian Christians of Nakhichevan, of Baku, of Sumgait, of Kirovabad?” he asked. “The last of these communities, the Armenian Christians of Nagorno-Karabakh, were driven out of their ancient homelands in 2023 by means of a large-scale military assault following a nine-month blockade designed to weaken the civilian population.”
In his written testimony, Eibner noted that Azerbaijan, backed by Turkey and thousands of jihadists brought from Syria, continues to occupy sovereign Armenian territory and to hold twenty Armenian Christian hostages in Baku as leverage to dictate the terms of what he called “a capitulation treaty.”
He warned that Azerbaijan’s ambitions now extend to Armenia itself. “Aliyev has set his sights on transforming the Republic of Armenia into what he calls ‘Western Azerbaijan’,” Eibner said. “Aliyev demands the subjugation of what is left of Christian Armenia and its integration into a Turco-Muslim sphere of influence as the price of peace… Christian Armenia thus faces a severe existential threat.”
Eibner urged lawmakers to act before the next atrocity. “We can’t just always respond to the beheadings, the executions, the blowing up of churches, the violence. We need to act proactively in a preventative way wherever we possibly can, and Armenia is one such case.”
Co-Chair Smith recounted his own confrontations with Azerbaijan’s dictator. “I met with Aliyev twice in Baku, argued with him about human rights and what he was doing to the Armenians and even his own people who are thrown into prison if they are calling for human rights and respect,” he said. Smith recalled chairing several hearings on Artsakh during Azerbaijan’s blockade, including testimony from former International Criminal Court Chief Prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo. “It was a genocide to use food as a weapon,” Smith said.
Smith condemned the welcome Aliyev receives in Washington. “Aliyev comes here and he’s well treated. I mean, the man has committed massive human rights abuses and continues to do it to this day,” he said. He then described how his Azerbaijan Democracy Act of 2015 (H.R. 4264) was blocked: “We were really making progress on it. And Podesta, you know, who is one of the big lobbyists here and the guy with lots of money? He was their [Azerbaijan’s] client. And he got the committee to kill my bill. So it shows that this place sometimes is not on the up and up.”
Documenting the Persecution of the Armenian Church
Eibner also testified about the Armenian government’s campaign against the Armenian Apostolic Church, which he linked directly to Turkish and Azerbaijani pressure. According to Eibner, the campaign began after Catholicos of All Armenians Karekin II condemned the ethnic cleansing of Artsakh, the holding of hostages in Baku, and the destruction of Armenian Christian heritage at a May 2025 World Council of Churches-sponsored conference in Bern, Switzerland.
“No sooner did he make this public statement than the persecution started severely,” Eibner told the Commission. He reported that fourteen churchmen, including the Catholicos, are facing criminal charges, with the Catholicos charged with obstructing justice and barred from traveling abroad. Eibner described the pattern as bearing “many striking resemblances to that undertaken by the Bolsheviks in Armenia, so far minus the murder.”
Eibner recounted visiting Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan in prison in Yerevan last February, in the same prison where Archbishop Bagrat Vardazarian was held by Stalin’s secret police before his execution in 1937. In a letter CSI delivered to Vice President Vance, the Archbishop wrote that he was imprisoned for bringing “my Christian faith and testimony into the public arena, in the hope that the Armenian nation and state remain true to their historic Christian tradition at a time of national crisis.”
“Unfortunately, Archbishop Bagrat’s letter was not heeded,” Eibner said. “To say that the United States and its Western partners have turned a blind eye to all of this is no overstatement.”
Calling for a U.S. Policy Reset
Eibner closed with a direct challenge to U.S. policymakers, who he said “seem quite content to hand management of the greater Middle East over to Turkey.” “If present trends continue and policies remain in place, even more Christian communities in the immense and expanding Turkish-Azerbaijani sphere of influence will be destroyed or wither away,” he warned.
“The U.S. can prevent this outcome by re-energizing its support for religious freedom in Turkey’s sphere of influence and prioritizing the survival of beleaguered Christians and religious minorities in its policymaking,” Eibner said. “If the United States has the will to place higher priority on religious freedom and begins to see some value in those persecuted for their Christian faith or identity, I have no doubt it has all the tools necessary to halt a further erosion.”
Pointing to President Reagan’s insistence on placing human rights at the top of his first meeting with Mikhail Gorbachev at Reykjavik, Eibner concluded: “May this example be revived by American political leadership and by the American public as we engage with Turkey and Azerbaijan regarding their growing spheres of influence.”

